Based on a recorded personal testimony. Adapted for publication by Carling Rygielski.
I cried almost the entire week leading up to my dad's death by Medical Assistance in Dying (MAiD), doing everything I could to stop it. In contrast to my despair, everyone around me seemed not only to endorse the decision but to believe it was merciful, painless… even joyful.
After sharing my opposition to MAiD online, I was threatened with being barred from the building where my dad was staying. I was repeatedly told that I was entitled to my own personal beliefs, but that I had no right to impose those beliefs on other people. I felt that I wasn't allowed to share my feelings with my dad or even express my opinion online without facing consequences. It was at that moment that my feelings shifted from emotional defeat and heartbreak to anger.
It's hard to describe what it felt like to be alone in the fight for my dad's life, up against healthcare workers, facility administrators, and members of my own family. My dad had lived with multiple sclerosis for 35 years but I don't believe this was the reason he chose to end his life by euthanasia.
My dad and I had a complicated relationship. He was often angry and wasn't one to share vulnerably. Still, looking back, I can't help but believe that he may have been deeply burdened by feelings of failure. For a man, once gregarious, full of adventure and independent spirit, his illness was inescapable evidence of his own powerlessness. Shortly before his death, he admitted that he felt he hadn't fulfilled his role as a father and provider, and that he couldn’t change it. He suggested that I go home, maybe even get together with friends, and that I shouldn’t be pressured to stay with him. He wanted to preserve any last vestige of ordinary life, of denial and silent bitterness that had been with him for so long. He wanted this reality to be forgotten, just as he felt forgotten. That same week, my mother shared with me privately that when I was born, my dad had dreamed of learning to dance for my wedding. I was heartbroken. The more I learned about my father, the less I felt I knew him as his daughter.
During his final week of life, being with him felt distant. He was withdrawn and cold toward my mom and me, but not toward his personal support workers. They cared for him regularly, and he felt loved by them. I'm not sure he felt that way about us. This level of avoidance is more than just an old man’s pride. It is a profound alienation from true love, a love which loves truth, the truth of his worth regardless of anything else. For me, this loss is more than an absence or disappearance of someone I love. It’s a rupture, past the point of no return. A moral dimension has now been foisted upon a reality which is otherwise universal and coming for us all: death. It changes not only how we understand the ending of a life, but how we understand human life itself, our attitude of responsibility to one another, our ability to suffer with and care for each other, and how to truly love.
In the hours leading up to his death, my dad repeatedly sought reassurance from the doctor that he wouldn't experience any pain. Not only did it seem like he was having doubts, but he also appeared to be hallucinating, reaching for things that weren't there or saying things that didn't make sense. He thought his remote control was his phone, his bed was his coffee table, and his box television set was his bed. He was awake for almost 48 hours straight, jerking his head constantly and having conversations with the air. Still, the doctors deemed him of sound mind to give his final yes. The “yes” which would rob his will and all future yeses.
The MAiD procedure is akin to a prison execution. The exact date, time and location were set, the setup was quick, cold and antiseptic. When the time came, we all huddled around my dad’s bed where it would take place. The healthcare workers struggled for almost two minutes to insert his IV. His veins had collapsed completely. It felt like time stopped moving. Another machine seemed to malfunction, and while the doctors were troubleshooting, I prayed to God that it had broken and the procedure would be delayed. I can't imagine what my father might have been experiencing. With a seemingly joyous send-off from healthcare workers, building administrators and family members, bidding him a “great ride” and “sweet dreams,” I couldn’t help but feel violated. For my father, and for myself.
My dad had spoken about MAiD for years, saying that he would consider it if his MS progressed to the point of causing intense physical suffering. His parents had also expressed similar intentions, although they did not proceed with it. I think that, over time, the idea had become not just familiar to him, but became a real and available service which could be provided for him. I thought I had time to change his mind, but it broke my heart to realize that this decision had been formed through years of cultural programming, family influence and his ultimate value: control.
I don't believe my dad chose to die because he was bedridden.
I believe he chose to die because he was in despair.
I experienced so much grief leading up to his death and while witnessing it. But the grief I experience now is different. I'm not sure if I'm in denial or if I've shut myself off emotionally. It worries me that I can talk about this horrible tragedy without crying. I feel hard of heart, and I'm struggling with what I recognize as a temptation toward self-righteous anger, vainglory and a bottomless frustration I can’t seem to get out of. I'm angry with the people involved in what I believe was a grave injustice, rather than having pity on them. I don't want to be stuck in my anger, but I also don't want to forget that this happened.
After going through this incredible loss and feeling like I was the only one who saw the injustice against body and soul, I’ve struggled wondering whether I'm going crazy or whether my response to all of this is normal. Talking about my experience has helped me feel less alone, but this sadness will never go away. My final memories of my dad are haunted by this wicked sacrament of violence, MAiD, his inclinations to it, and my perception of our culture is in complete shock. It’s time that we wake up to this reality, lest we lose sight of our shared humanity.
Help is available for those who are suffering after the euthanasia death of their loved ones. Please contact Compassionate Community Care for resources and support programs available. If you or someone you know is considering Medical Assistance in Dying (MAD) or euthanasia and wants alternatives, and/or assistance for life-affirming options and help available please contact us at 1-855-675-8749